We may earn a commission when you purchase through our affiliate links, at no extra cost to you. This helps support our work and allows us to continue providing unbiased, expert diamond advice.
Note: Most prices, product details, or comparisons mentioned in this article are based on information available from our trusted partner we frequently reference: Blue Nile. We may earn a commission when you purchase through our affiliate links, at no extra cost to you. This helps support our work and allows us to continue providing unbiased, expert diamond advice.
James Allen’s True Hearts™ line is discontinued. Signet Jewelers announced in March 2026 that it would wind down the James Allen e-commerce site, and the transition completed in early August 2026. jamesallen.com now redirects to bluenile.com. If you came here for a super-ideal, hearts-and-arrows stone, the live equivalent is Astor by Blue Nile.
Summary in a few lines:
- True Hearts™ was James Allen’s in-house super-ideal line, and it ended with the site in early August 2026 after a wind-down announced in March 2026.
- jamesallen.com now redirects to bluenile.com (we checked the redirect on 18 August 2026) and the James Allen name continues as a proprietary collection inside Blue Nile.
- The live super-ideal line is Astor by Blue Nile, which comes with a GemEx light-performance report rather than a brand-name cut grade.
- Astor stones are NOT eligible for Blue Nile’s Diamond Price Match Guarantee, so weigh that before paying a super-ideal premium.
- Existing James Allen warranties and lifetime service plans are being honoured, and order history plus prior support conversations transferred to Blue Nile.
Table of Contents
Toggle
What Happened to James Allen True Hearts?
True Hearts went down with the store that sold it. Signet Jewelers announced in March 2026 that it would wind down the James Allen e-commerce site, and the transition completed in early August 2026. jamesallen.com now redirects to bluenile.com, and we confirmed that redirect on 18 August 2026.
The name did not vanish, though. James Allen continues as a proprietary collection inside Blue Nile.
The commercial backdrop was not subtle: James Allen revenue fell from $422M to $142M over roughly two years, which is the kind of slide that ends with a redirect rather than a relaunch.
Fact: Signet acquired James Allen in 2017 for $328M and acquired Blue Nile in 2022. Two rival brands, one owner, and eventually one website.
Anything beyond those points (the fate of specific search filters, or whether individual True Hearts stones were carried across) is unconfirmed, so ask Blue Nile support directly rather than trusting a forum post.
True Hearts: What the Line Actually Was
True Hearts was James Allen’s branded super-ideal tier: round, princess and cushion stones picked for hearts-and-arrows symmetry on top of the highest cut and polish grades. It was a brand tier, not a laboratory grade. On a GIA report, a True Hearts stone read simply “Excellent” in cut.
James Allen marketed the line as a sliver of world production (fewer than 1% by the brand’s own count) with the internal symmetry to show a clean starburst pattern. That number was the brand’s own, never an independently graded threshold.
What the line genuinely delivered was consistency. In twelve years of inspecting stones for readers, we’ve found that the large majority of True Hearts diamonds did show a crisp, matched pattern, but not every single one was perfect in it.
And the badge only ever spoke to cut, polish and symmetry. Clarity and color were graded separately, so a True Hearts stone with a visible SI2 inclusion could easily disappoint next to a plain Excellent VS2.
Hearts & Arrows in Diamonds, in Plain Terms
Hearts and arrows (H&A) is a pattern that appears in a round brilliant cut to very tight symmetry: eight arrowheads radiating from the centre seen through the table, and eight hearts around the perimeter seen through the pavilion. You need a special viewer to see either one.
The pattern is a symptom, not the prize. It tells you the facets are paired and aligned precisely, and that alignment is what sends light back out through the table instead of leaking it out of the side.
How Do You Read an Ideal Scope or ASET Image?
Three colours carry the whole story. Red areas show where light is returning to the table, black lines give the contrast between facets, and white areas show light leakage.
So an ideally cut stone shows strong red, clean black contrast, and very little white. That’s the entire reading exercise.
What Does It Take to Cut a Hearts & Arrows Diamond?
Craftsmanship and sacrificed weight. The facets have to be cut and aligned within very small tolerances, and a slight variation is enough to break the pattern.
That is why H&A stones are relatively rare and sold at a premium. You are paying for cutting time and for rough that was ground away rather than kept as carat weight.
Hearts and Arrows vs Ideal Cut: What’s the Difference?
Ideal, GIA calls it “Excellent”, is a graded band with tolerances. Hearts and arrows is a symmetry pattern that sits near the tight end of that same band. Every genuine H&A stone is an Excellent cut; most Excellent stones are not full H&A. The difference is precision within one grade, not two different categories.
Here is the part nobody selling a premium tier says out loud: the hearts pattern itself is invisible in normal wear. You cannot see it without a viewer, across a counter or on a hand.
What you can see is light return, and a well-proportioned Excellent stone with sensible table and depth percentages often returns light indistinguishably from a badged super-ideal at arm’s length. The premium buys measurable precision, not always visible precision.
Want to test that yourself? Set one filter combination (Excellent cut, H color, VS2 clarity, 1 carat, GIA certified, no fluorescence) and feel free to run it on Blue Nile’s diamond search, then compare the videos where imaging is available.
What Is Astor Ideal Cut?
Astor by Blue Nile is Blue Nile’s super-ideal cut line. Stones in it are selected for light performance beyond an ordinary top-band cut, and each one comes with a GemEx light-performance report, a third-party measurement of brilliance, fire and sparkle, not a laboratory cut grade. One condition matters: Astor diamonds are not eligible for Blue Nile’s Diamond Price Match Guarantee.
That GemEx report is the practical difference from a plain Excellent listing. Instead of a single word in a grade box, you get measured light-performance readings on that individual stone.
Put simply, “Astor ideal cut” is a retailer tier layered on top of GIA’s grading, in the same way True Hearts was. GIA still prints “Excellent”, and the brand name appears nowhere on the report.
Astor stones sit inside the main inventory rather than on a separate site, so you can browse Blue Nile’s current diamond inventory and filter from there. Filter labels change over time; if you cannot find the tier, ask their support rather than guessing.
Astor: The Not-so-Good Side
The price-match exclusion is the real one. Because Astor is carved out of the Diamond Price Match Guarantee, you cannot lean on that policy to trim the super-ideal premium.
Second, a GemEx report measures light performance and nothing else. It says nothing about clarity, color or durability, and it will not rescue a stone with an inclusion you can see.
Third, availability by shape and size moves constantly, and we will not quote you a stock count we cannot see. Check the live search on the day you shop.
Astor by Blue Nile vs. True Hearts
Astor is the closest live equivalent to True Hearts, and it is the only one of the two you can actually buy, since the James Allen site closed in August 2026. What we will not tell you is that the two lines are cut to identical standards, or that either one is superior. Both tiers are proprietary, and neither was benchmarked publicly against the other.
So judge the stone, not the badge. A GIA report showing Excellent cut with Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry, plus a GemEx reading and a 360° video you have actually watched, tells you more than any trademark.
If you owned or wanted a True Hearts round, the honest translation is this: you wanted a super-ideal round brilliant. That target still exists, and it is buyable.
What a Super-Ideal Cut Buys You, and What It Doesn’t
A super-ideal cut buys the tightest facet alignment available, which means maximum light return through the table, a crisp contrast pattern, and lively scintillation as the hand moves. What it does not buy is better clarity, better color, better durability, or a visible hearts pattern in daily wear.
The cut band is where your money works hardest. A drop from Excellent down to Good is something you will spot immediately, while the step from Excellent to super-ideal is measured with equipment far more often than it is noticed by people.
So the sequence we’d give any reader with a fixed budget is unchanged: secure the top cut grade first, then buy an eye-clean clarity, then spend whatever is left on carat weight. Never buy size before cut.
Remember this: a super-ideal badge is a promise about one of the 4Cs. The other three still need checking, one at a time.
Super-Ideal Cuts on GIA and AGS Certificates
No major lab certifies a brand tier. GIA prints one of five cut grades (Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor) and a super-ideal round reads “Excellent”, full stop. AGS graded cut numerically instead, so a top stone showed 0 in cut, 0 in polish and 0 in symmetry, written as AGS 000 and often marketed as “triple zero”.
The triple-zero label has drifted over the years, and AGS said so itself before removing the passage from its site:
“Technically an AGS triple zero was a diamond with a 0 grade in cut (Ideal), 0 in clarity (IF or Flawless) and 0 in Color (D). AGS 000. However, sellers (internet sellers at first) started calling diamonds with 0 cut triple zeros because proportions, polish & symmetry all had to be 0 to get the cut grade AGS 0.”, American Gem Society
Tip: “Triple Excellent” is not a grade at all. It is sales shorthand for Excellent cut, polish and symmetry, and no lab issues it as a single designation.
The takeaway for anyone hunting a True Hearts or Astor certificate: stop looking for the brand name on the report. It was never there, and its absence is not a red flag.
Your Old True Hearts Order, Warranty, and Service Plan
Your coverage carried over. Existing James Allen warranties and lifetime service plans are being honoured, and order history along with prior support conversations transferred to Blue Nile. In practice that means a stone bought as a True Hearts diamond years ago is still serviceable, just through a different support desk.
Details past that point are unconfirmed. Repair turnaround, upgrade terms and resizing specifics on legacy orders are things we cannot verify from the outside.
So contact Blue Nile support with your original James Allen order number and get the answer in writing. Ask before you ship anything.
How Should You Shop a Super-Ideal Diamond Now?
Shop the specifications, then the tier. Set your cut grade at the top of the scale, filter for a GIA report, pick a clarity that is clean to your eye, and only then decide whether a super-ideal line such as Astor is worth its premium to you. Compare at least one badged stone against one plain Excellent before paying.
1. Lock the cut grade before anything else
Filter to Excellent cut, Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry, and refuse to move off that. Every other compromise is cheaper than a compromise on cut.
2. Look at the stone, not the label
Open the 360° video and watch the pattern as the stone turns. Leakage, dark centres and a lazy pattern show up on screen, badge or no badge.
3. Read the report line by line
Check table and depth percentages, polish, symmetry and fluorescence on the GIA report itself. If a listing shows a GemEx light-performance report as well, read that as a second opinion on light return rather than a replacement for the grading report.
4. Price the premium against a plain Excellent
Put a super-ideal candidate beside a strong Excellent-cut stone of the same carat, color and clarity, and look at the gap. We won’t quote a figure, because inventory and pricing shift weekly. Build the comparison on Blue Nile’s diamond search on the day you buy.
5. Settle the setting last
Choose the stone first, then the mount. If you are ready for that step, feel free to browse Blue Nile’s engagement ring settings once your diamond is chosen.
Summary: Final Words on True Hearts and Super-Ideal Diamonds
True Hearts is discontinued. Signet wound down the James Allen site in early August 2026, jamesallen.com redirects to bluenile.com, and the James Allen name now lives on as a collection inside Blue Nile.
The line was a brand tier, never a lab grade, and its stones always read “Excellent” on a GIA report.
Astor by Blue Nile is the live super-ideal option, backed by a GemEx light-performance report and excluded from the Diamond Price Match Guarantee. We are not claiming it matches True Hearts standard for standard, because that has never been established either way.
The durable part of this answer is the cut logic. Top cut grade first, eye-clean clarity second, carat weight last, and a super-ideal premium is worth paying only if the individual stone earns it on its report and its video.
Remember, every diamond is a one-off, and the badge on the listing is the least individual thing about it.
Frequently Asked Questions on True Hearts & Astor
What is Astor ideal cut?
Astor by Blue Nile is Blue Nile’s super-ideal cut line. Stones are selected for light performance and each comes with a GemEx light-performance report measuring brilliance, fire and sparkle. It is a retailer tier, not a GIA grade, and Astor diamonds are not eligible for Blue Nile’s Diamond Price Match Guarantee.
Can you still buy James Allen True Hearts diamonds?
No. The James Allen e-commerce site was wound down after a March 2026 announcement, with the transition completing in early August 2026, and jamesallen.com now redirects to bluenile.com. The James Allen name continues as a proprietary collection inside Blue Nile, and the closest live super-ideal line is Astor by Blue Nile.
What was a True Hearts diamond?
True Hearts was James Allen’s trademarked super-ideal line: round, princess and cushion diamonds chosen for hearts-and-arrows symmetry along with top cut and polish grades. It described cut precision only. Clarity and color were graded separately, so not every True Hearts stone was a strong buy overall.
What is the difference between hearts and arrows and ideal cut?
Ideal (GIA “Excellent”) is a graded band with tolerances, while hearts and arrows is a symmetry pattern found at the tight end of that band. Every true H&A stone is an Excellent cut, but most Excellent stones are not full H&A. The pattern needs a special viewer to see at all.
Is Astor by Blue Nile the same as True Hearts?
Not established. Both are proprietary super-ideal tiers, and neither company published a shared benchmark that would let anyone call them identical or rank one above the other. Astor is the closest live equivalent, and it should be judged on each stone’s GIA report, its GemEx reading and its video.
Do GIA certificates mention True Hearts or Astor?
No. GIA prints one of five cut grades (Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair or Poor) and a super-ideal stone reads “Excellent” with no brand name. AGS graded cut numerically, showing 0 in cut, polish and symmetry, known as AGS 000 or “triple zero”.
Are old James Allen warranties still valid?
Yes. Existing James Allen warranties and lifetime service plans are being honoured, and order history plus prior support conversations transferred to Blue Nile. Specific repair timelines and upgrade terms on legacy orders are unconfirmed, so contact Blue Nile support with your original order number.
Is a super-ideal cut worth the extra money?
Sometimes. A super-ideal cut buys the tightest facet alignment and maximum light return, but the hearts pattern is invisible without a viewer and the premium does nothing for clarity, color or durability. Compare a badged stone against a strong plain Excellent of the same specs before deciding.
Still not sure where to buy your diamond?
We always recommend shopping diamonds online, and we’ve written a full guide to shopping diamonds like a pro for readers starting from scratch.
Blue Nile is our remaining recommended retailer: a very wide loose-diamond inventory across sizes, imaging on most of it, solid support, and the home of the Astor super-ideal line as well as the James Allen collection.
You may also want to read:
- James Allen Has Closed: What Happened & Where to Buy
- Astor by Blue Nile Collection Review
- Blue Nile Diamonds & Jewelry Review: Is Blue Nile Cheap?
- Understanding Diamond Cuts: Grade Scale and Chart
- Diamond Cuts vs. Shapes: What’s the Difference?
